Friday, February 24, 2012

“It had been a merry, scary season”….BSC Super Mystery # 4: Baby-sitters’ Christmas Chiller

Memory Reaction

This was after my time. The fact that I’ve already covered most of the books I actually read, is sort of messing up my format lately, but there’s not much I can do about that.

Revisited Reaction

This book really has three mysteries that only intertwine slightly. But they all take place in the days leading up to another Christmas in BSC-land.

First: Someone’s breaking into homes in Kristy’s neighborhood, trashing them, and leaving messages that say “naughty” painted on a wall somewhere. Someone also tries to break into Abby’s and Mrs. Porter’s houses, but just leaves a note saying “nice.” Of course, the BSC has to jump in and try to investigate. They even volunteer their baby-sitting services to the families who’ve been victimized as an excuse to poke around. They help figure out that it’s a gardener that several families in the area had recently dropped for a different company. And because it’s the BSC, they end up helping the police set the guy up, by having Watson fire the guy, then pretend to go out of town. So the police catch the guy and everyone (except the culprit) is happy.

Meanwhile: Mallory and Jessi are walking home from a rehearsal for their church Christmas pageant, and they find a woman on the street with no memory of how she got there, and no ID or belongings. She’s also pregnant, because regular amnesia isn’t dramatic enough for a Super Mystery. Anyway, this woman (who they’re calling Mary) ends up staying at the Pike’s for a few days. Then she goes into labor. During a snowstorm. The only surprise is that it happens the day before Christmas Eve and not midnight on Christmas. Anyway, Mallory helps track down the woman’s identity by tracing a label in her clothes and sending the picture of a ring to a jewelry store near it. Or something equally ridiculous. It turns out the woman was taking train to travel after visiting some friends in Boston, but before going home. Her husband was in Australia on business, so no one was really looking for her. She got off the train and was mugged or something. But giving birth started bringing her memory back, because otherwise it’d be too depressing for a Christmas story.

Lastly: Stacey and Claudia are visiting Mr. McGill in New York and are being harassed by someone. Weird things keep happening in the apartment building…the lights go out in the hallway outside their door, they get stuck in an elevator, someone dumps red paint in the elevator that looked like blood, etc. Also, someone leaves a creepy note on their door and a picture of Stacey that was taken by someone following her. The worst thing is that Stacey almost falls/maybe was pushed in front of a subway (but was fine, obviously). At first they think it may be Ethan, but they finally confront him. It turns out that his ex-girlfriend, Cybil, lives in Stacey’s building and has been stalking them. She leaves them a note to meet in the basement, and like idiots they go. There’s a whole dramatic confrontation, complete with a power failure, but at the end Ethan just brings her to her parents to get her help. It’s really anti-climactic.


  • Claudia outfit: "She had braided her long jet-black into a single braid with narrow red, blue, green, yellow, orange, and purple ribbons woven in. Her short red turtleneck dress had a braided yellow belt, and she was wearing purple tights, yellow scrunch socks, and black Docs. Her earrings were in the shape of Christmas trees, but they were painted in rainbow colors, instead of just green. On some people this might have been too much, but on looked fabulous." - of course it did.
  • The funniest part’s that when the police arrest the gardener, the BSC runs out of Abby’s house to watch, and Watson, Mrs. Brewer, and Mrs. Stevenson keep calling out telling to them to stop. As though they’ve finally decided to set limits with their children’s crime fighting.
  • However, these same adults don’t have any issue with their kids helping to organize a neighborhood watch.
  • Ethan tells Stacey her Dad’s apartment building was built over an old graveyard. Really? Why is everything always built over a graveyard?
  • When Mal goes to the police station to give her statement about finding Mary, they tell her to bring her parents. And Mrs. Pike goes! Someone in the Stoneybrook police department actually treats the BSC members like the minors that they are. I’m shocked.
  • Most of the BSC goes to Abby’s house for a Hanukkah party and after giving us all a lesson about the holiday, they hang out with Anna. But it seems weird that Anna wouldn’t also invite her own friends to it. I don’t think this is the first time this has happened with an Abby book.
  • What’s worse is that when they hear that the Papadakises house was robbed, they all take off to “investigate” and just leave poor Anna behind.
  • One weird thing’s that Kristy finds a note in her mailbox that says, “nice” and she writes it off as some girl who may have a crush on Sam or Charlie. But then later, the guy actually breaks into Abby’s house and Morbidda Destiny’s house to leave them “nice” notes. Why the switch?
  • Stacey and Claudia go to a coffee bar in the city…they seem young for that, but maybe people do start drinking it at that age now.
  • I don’t mean to judge, but what was Mary’s husband doing going to Australia when his wife was 9 months pregnant?
  • Two of the homes that were broken into happened when the people were on vacation. Now, this is in the weeks leading up to Christmas. Do most people go out of town the week before Christmas, but come home before it? I usually hear about people leaving for the holiday itself.
  • Who uses a gardener in December anyway?
  • Apparently Mal and Jessi put random facts about horses in the club notebook, so Stacey and Claudia know that horses in harnesses only appear in Central Park. Or something like that. It makes Mallory and Jessi sound really lame, and maybe that’s the point. But seriously, they like horses so much they can’t do anything without mentioning them?
  • A salesperson at Tiffany’s lets Stacey and Claud try on jewelry. That seems very kind of her. Oh, and of course Stacey’s dad has already promised her diamond earrings after she finishes high school. I wonder if he told her that before or after she asked for a diamond ring?
  • Mallory mentions saying grace before eating dinner with her family. Now, I remember a lot of scenes with the Pikes eating meals, and I don’t think they’ve ever mentioned saying grace before them. I guess they did that to support this new backstory about the Pikes ALWAYS helping out with their church’s Christmas pageant. Because I don’t think we’ve ever heard them talk about church before.
  • Dawn’s in this book, since she’s visiting for the holidays. She says she wants a "bi-coastal" sleepover with all her friends someday. Which has already happened.
  • Also, does Dawn think the word “bi-coastal” sounds cooler than it is?
  • The entire Prologue and Epilogue of this book is done as a notebook entry from Jessi. It’s really annoying, I hate her handwriting.
  • Most of the girls are at a sleepover at Kristy’s when Mrs. Porter’s house is robbed. Watson and Kristy's mom don't let the girls run out and play detective when it happens (in the middle of the night). However, they do go the next day, and I think she’s amused by the girls’ detective act. She keeps smiling as they subtly try and ask questions. It makes me like her a little.
  • It was really obvious that Ethan had an ex-girlfriend in the building, and that she was the one behind everything. I wish they had just made her bitchy, instead of out-and-out crazy.
  • So apparently, Cybil tells the doorman in Stacey’s building that she’s friends with Stacey and they like to play jokes on each other. But I can’t believe that the doorman wouldn’t speak up when the “jokes” involve dumping paint all over the building’s elevator.
  • If you’re wondering how the girls have so much time on their hands…SMS closed for winter break a few days sooner than expected because of issues with the heat. Only in BSC-land can they get extra days off and not have to make them up at some point down the line.


SJSiff said...

I've seen more and more high schoolers drinking coffee in the last few years (until last year I was a sports coach), but not middle schoolers yet. I also live in the Seattle area, so that might have something to do with it.

I agree that the church stuff with the Pikes seems out of place. There's very little mention of religion in these books period. Mary Anne told the nasty prejudice family in Keep Out, Claudia! that she and her dad attend a church once a in a while, but it's never seen. Jessi will very occasionally say vaguely religious things (for example, in Jessi and the Awful Secret, she narrated that she prayed her anorexic friend would get help, but she might have meant hoped). And Claudia's a godmother, having been formally made so at her cousin's christening. But the Pikes don't even get these vagues lines before this book!

And not only do the SMS students not have to make up the extra days off, they get more two-week vacations the rest of the year!

Anonymous said...

I live in Seattle as well and I went to middle school in the late 90's. We did drink coffee after church every week. And in high school everyone drank it because after 10th grade it was open campus and we had two coffee stands right next to the school.

I also agree about Anna and how it was kind of messed up that she didn't have any friends over or that they didn't ask her to come with them atleast when they left to go in check out the breakin. Also in Abby's lucky 13 they had a sleepover and she invited like two friend while Abby had the whole BSC and they even Shannon count as one of her friends. So really she only had one friend.

Marjan said...

Did anyone else scream out "Really?!" when the crazy girl's name turned out to be Cybil? Am i the only one in the BSC universe that saw that Sally Field's movie where she's has 35 personalities?

Seneca Syczyk said...

I just want to let you know how much joy this blog brings me. -Kelly

toscler said...

The broken boiler days off could just be some of the banked days off that a school district always throws into the schedule just in case. Akin to snow days. It happened to my school as well. Once you reach X many days off, it starts cutting into summer break.

They said that he broke into Mrs. Porter's and the Stevenson‎'s because he wanted to be more agressive about them staying nice. Or something like that.

The Stacey/Claudia storyline was the worst. With all the other people that live in the building and on Stacey's floor, no one else noticed? Weird. I actually enjoyed the other two plots.

sbo said...

Hello there, simply become alert to your weblog thru Google, and fosbobetund that it’s really informative. I’m gonna watch out for brussels

Anonymous said...

This is my great pleasure to visit your website and to enjoy your excellent post. I found many valuable things to learn in this article. Please keep on posting such quality articles. Thank you for sharing this article to all of us. resveratrol

wanderingfrog said...

Only in BSC-land can they get extra days off and not have to make them up at some point down the line.

I think that spending twelve years in eighth grade more than balances out those extra days off. ;-)

Melanie Raye said...

I have a feeling that in book #4 "Mary Anne Saves the Day", it is mentioned that MA and her dad pray before dinner every night...

booboobrewer said...

"Did anyone else scream out "Really?!" when the crazy girl's name turned out to be Cybil?"

Not reading it for the first time as a kid...I just thought it was an unusual name, haha.

Re: drinking coffee, Mary Anne freaks out about the idea of drinking coffee in Winter Vacation because her dad told her it will stunt her growth. I guess models Stacey and Claudia don't have to worry about that ;)

Anonymous said...

Wasnt' there some book that daid Stacey wasn't allowed to drink coffee?

Au pair UK said...

Hi, I must say that you have made some good points in the post. I performed searches on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog. Thanks for sharing this information.

Jason Bennett said...

I Finally Got Helped  !! I'm so excited right now, I just have to share my testimony on this Forum.. The feeling of being loved takes away so much burden from our shoulders. I had all this but I made a big mistake when I cheated on my wife with another woman  and my wife left me for over 4 months after she found out..  I was lonely, sad and devastated. Luckily I was directed to a very powerful spell caster Dr Emu who helped me cast a spell of reconciliation on our Relationship and he brought back my wife and now she loves me far more than ever.. I'm so happy with life now. Thank you so much Dr Emu, kindly Contact  Dr Emu Today and get any kind of help you want.. Via Email or Call/WhatsApp cell number  +2347012841542 Website (