Wednesday, September 8, 2010

“Some bratty little kid is driving you nuts because she’s lying her head off”………BSC # 128: Claudia and the Little Liar

Memory Reaction

This is another one I never read as a kid….

Revisited Reaction

This is a sitting job-heavy plot, which is usually a bad sign. Claudia has a sitting job for the Braddocks, and when she got there, Mrs. Braddock says to make sure Haley does her homework. Haley shows Claudia some book report as proof that it’s done, and she’s allowed to watch TV. When the Braddocks get home, Claudia says, “Well, Haley finished her report on The Great Brain.” Only, Mrs. Braddock knows that the book report was from last month, and Haley ends up grounded.

Haley blames Claudia, and starts telling her friends that the BSC members are spies who report bad behavior to kids’ parents. At first, only some kids listen to her. Then, in an amazing coincidence, Claudia has several more sitting jobs for the Braddocks. Haley uses this to try to make Claudia look bad, and she ends up getting in more trouble. But this actually helps her convince other kids that the BSC is out to get them. At the time, Haley’s playing on a girls basketball team that Kristy’s coaching, and this turns into a forum to spread her complaints.

The BSC decides they need to solve the problem, and they call the Braddocks asking to do a "role play" with Haley. I’m sure Mr. and Mrs. Braddock were glad to get that call, because otherwise they wouldn’t have had any idea how to help their daughter. Anyway, the role play gets Haley to admit that she lied about homework because she was having trouble in school, her parents decide to get her a tutor, blah, blah, blah. At the end, Haley tries to lie to a ref at the team’s first basketball game. But after a look from Kristy, she admits the truth. And the team wins! Happy endings all around.

The subplot’s somewhat more interesting than all the Haley drama. Claudia’s currently dating a guy named Josh, who she met while being temporarily sent back to seventh grade. Apparently she had been dating another seventh-grade guy, but dumped him for Josh. She has a lot in common with Josh, and he’s generally a nice guy – he even helps her design and sew uniforms that Claud’s making for Kristy’s basketball team. The problem’s that Claudia’s just not feeling the chemistry. While, they have kissed, Claudia just doesn’t have a huge desire to do it often.

Claud’s afraid to say anything, because she doesn’t want to ruin the friendship. But eventually they talk, and she finds out Josh feels the same way about her. They decide to try just being friends, and since they do hang out together at the end, it may actually happen.


  • Now, I may be stating the obvious, but isn’t one of the reasons for having a baby-sitter so that the parents know the kid doesn’t get in trouble? I mean, the sitter doesn’t have to tell the parents everything, but she isn’t there on a play date.
  • I’m guessing this isn’t the first time Claudia will meet a guy who can help her design clothes, but doesn’t want to kiss her. This is especially true if she gets a job in fashion. Of course, Claudia getting a job in fashion may be a sign of the apocalypse, so I try not to think about it too much.
  • Claudia tells Josh that she can’t go out on Saturday because it’s her dad’s birthday. So, on Saturday she goes to wish him happy birthday, and he tells her it’s not for another week. That seems like a pretty hard mistake to make.
  • I wouldn’t have expected Becca and Charlotte to join a basketball team, but they’re both players on Kristy’s team. So are Vanessa and Haley (who only wanted to be Krushers’ cheerleaders). I’m not saying that interest in softball has to equal interest in basketball, I was just surprised to see it.
  • One of the jobs for Haley and Matt’s when Mr. and Mrs. Braddock go to the elementary school for a meeting about the spring dance. But since when do elementary schools have dances? And what other dance would they be planning? It just seems weird.
  • While Abby’s sitting at the Rodowskis’, the kids make a reference to Noah Seger living next store, which is a reference to this lovely book. I was happy to see this, because if you’re going to have crazy-unrealistic books, you should at least have continuity.
  • Claudia doesn’t know a lot of sign language, so Haley translates for Matt. She tells Claud that Matt needs poster paint for a school assignment, but doesn’t have any. Claudia says she has some at home, and she calls Stacey to get it for her. Mrs. McGill actually drives Stacey to Claudia’s house, waits while Stacey goes in and gets the paint, and then drives her to the Braddocks. It ends up being a fool’s errand, cause Haley was lying about it. But even if it wasn’t, this seems like a lot of effort for a second-grader’s homework.
  • Also, taking advantage of your brother’s handicap to trick your baby-sitter seems a bit bitchy.
  • I really want to get my hands on the books where Claudia’s temporarily sent back to seventh grade. They sound like they’d be fun to recap.
  • Claudia calls the Pikes because Matt wants to borrow a book from Nicky (and can’t use the phone himself for obvious reasons). Mrs. Pike says Mr. Pike took the kids to a movie. Now, this is on a Wednesday night. It seems odd that elementary school kids would be going to the movie on a school night.
  • I guess Haley’s rumors are effective, because Charlotte, who has shown Stacey her diary in the past, won’t show her a random school assignment.
  • Stacey uses the word “composition” to describe something Charlotte was writing. Does anyone actually use that word? Especially kids?
  • When did Mary Anne go to counseling? Because even though I didn’t read this book as a kid, I remember it being in referenced in other books I DID read. But I never read the book where it first happened.
  • Of course, when Haley starts bitching to other kids in town, Kristy’s paranoid that the BSC’s doomed. She even worries that the Ramseys (who have a daughter IN the club) would stop using them. Her paranoia’s getting a bit old.
  • Stacey says that she and Robert are friends now, even though it took a lot of time after their breakup to get to that point. I feel like that must have happened in a book I never read, and it makes me want to find it.
  • Claudia says that Mary Anne has never gotten a complaint about scheduling jobs/her role as secretary. But, haven’t there been entire books about fights over jobs? Maybe the complaints weren’t specifically about Mary Anne, but they still happened.
  • We keep hearing about how Haley’s “lies” include her using the phone when she’s supposed to be studying, and then pretending she was asking someone about homework. Now….didn't Mary Anne do this all the time in the early books? Because her dad wouldn’t let her use the phone otherwise, right? So, are they saying Mary Anne was “acting out” when she did that?


Unknown said...

i think it's mentioned in the babysitters club secret santa where mary anne goes to dr.reese to seek counseling for the first time( could it be because of Logan bruno)? lol. but yeah, i would so love to read a book where mary anne go seek counseling.

i think book 101 is the one where claudia goes back to the 7th grade due to low grades. Its called Claudia Kishi, Middle School Dropout. You'll love the book. It pretty much continues till book 113 where she's offered a chance to go back to the 8th grade, where she accepts. That's also the one where her and Josh date for the first time and where her and Mark broke up.

HelenB said...

I think Stacey and Robert are friends again in the Europe trip Super Special - is that the one where some other girls keeps hitting on him and she yells at Stacey when he's not interested? I'd more or less stopped reading the books by then, but I *think* it mentioned Robert going through some depression stuff.

This is a pretty bizarre book. You'd have thought that the girls would have actually have had to report bad behaviour to parents before this. Or maybe the BSC saw that as a sign of weakness!

Sarah said...

I don't know about schools now, but my elementary school had an annual sock hop every spring. Maybe they were planning something like that.

Also I really can't see Haley being a "bad" kid. She was always so sweet and helpful.

Meghan Edge said...

ha ha ha ha- Mary Ann was in counseling? News to me.

I love the snark that snuck into the recap paragraph. Of course the parents have no clue what to do with children without the BSC telling them!

I used the word composition AND attended dances in elementary school. Mostly in the third grade.

megan s said...

I *think* that MA said she went to counseling after she found out she went to her grandmothers for a while? I think. Then she went again after her friend dies in the car accident.

They never actually tell about her going the first time tho. Like, there was never a book about it.

Alycia said...

The first time we see Mary Anne in counseling is when her friend dies in the car accident. On her way to therapy she mentions that she went when Richard and Sharon first got married but she never told anyone.

And #5 of the Friends Forever books, Stacey says Robert is still depressed and clingy and she tries to introduce him to her new boyfriend. I know that's after this series, but it's supposed to be at the same time, so yea for continuity!

Anonymous said...

Sarah- Haley??? When was Haley ever sweet and helpful? In one book she stole Mary Anne's cat. That's a sure sign of a future mega-bitch if you ask me.

Jesus Warrior said...

Unless I've forgotten a later book, it was Kerry Bruno who took Mary Anne's cat. She took it home with her because she thought Mary Anne had abandoned it.

Unknown said...

to anonymous-

that was kerry bruno who stole Mary Anne's cat. Not Haley. Kerry stole Mary Anne's cat in book 25 of the babysitter's club.

Maddy said...

#119, Stacey's Ex-Boyfriend, revolves around Robert being depressed and Stacey trying to help him, so I think that's where they became friends again.

I think the first time Mary Anne's therapy came up was in Chain Letter.

(Why do I know this stuff?)

winstonegbert said...

If my best friend was Kristy, I had a possessive douch of a boyfriend, and my stepmother put my homework in the oven, I would probably need counselling too. Poor MaryAnne!

Melanie Raye said...

I first heard about MA going to counselling in the Chain Letter book.

Jason Bennett said...

I Finally Got Helped  !! I'm so excited right now, I just have to share my testimony on this Forum.. The feeling of being loved takes away so much burden from our shoulders. I had all this but I made a big mistake when I cheated on my wife with another woman  and my wife left me for over 4 months after she found out..  I was lonely, sad and devastated. Luckily I was directed to a very powerful spell caster Dr Emu who helped me cast a spell of reconciliation on our Relationship and he brought back my wife and now she loves me far more than ever.. I'm so happy with life now. Thank you so much Dr Emu, kindly Contact  Dr Emu Today and get any kind of help you want.. Via Email or Call/WhatsApp cell number  +2347012841542 Website (